McCulloch and Shannon, 1949–1950
Letters between Warren McCulloch and Claude Shannon, from McCulloch's papers at the American Philosophical Society.
Two Americans in England
In the summer of 1949 Warren McCulloch lectured across France, England and Scotland. His visit was the occasion of the Ratio Club's first meeting, on 14 September 1949, where he was the guest speaker. McCulloch met Claude Shannon at a talk in Chicago that year and invited him to the Macy conferences on cybernetics, which McCulloch chaired. In the autumn of 1950 Shannon spent two months in Europe. Eight letters between them survive in McCulloch's papers; in two of them, each tells the other what he found in England.
What they saw

Warren S. McCulloch to Claude Shannon
20 October 1949
“I am even sorrier not to have seen you this summer. I have been lecturing at an incredible rate in France, England, and Scotland to groups of psychiatrists, electro-encephalographers, neurophysiologists, engineers, logicians, mathematicians, and even anatomists, to say nothing of neurosurgeons. It was always on the same general theme of the circuit action of the nervous system, sometimes on its servo aspects, sometimes on its digital aspects. … I wish you had been with me the day I spent in Manchester with Turing and Jones. Williams was unfortunately away. I had always thought of his tubes for memory as something which existed on paper. It was a delight to see them in action.”
Carbon copy. Warren S. McCulloch Papers, American Philosophical Society. “Jones” is not identified; historians have suggested R. V. Jones, John Lennard-Jones and Eric Malcolm Jones. F. C. Williams's cathode-ray tubes were the memory of the Manchester computer.
Portrait: MIT Museum.

Claude E. Shannon to Warren S. McCulloch
30 November 1950
“Sorry I'm so late in answering your letter of October 4, but I have just returned from a two-month trip to Europe. I was amazed at the amount of activity there, especially in England, on Information Theory, Cybernetics, computing machines, and the like. The programming techniques on the Edsac at Cambridge are probably in advance of anything in this country.”
Signed original on Bell Telephone Laboratories letterhead. Warren S. McCulloch Papers, American Philosophical Society. The EDSAC, built by Maurice Wilkes's team at Cambridge, ran its first program in May 1949.
Portrait: MIT Photo Service, 1958; MIT Museum. Public domain.
The other letters
- 24 May 1949, McCulloch to Shannon: sends unpublished mimeographed papers and hopes to visit him that summer.
- 2 June 1949, Shannon to McCulloch: “There is considerable activity here in information theory, computing machines and other ‘Cybernetic’ questions”; he encloses reprints, among them his paper on programming a computer to play chess.
- 8 June 1949, McCulloch's secretary to Shannon: McCulloch has left for meetings in Atlantic City and may call on him in mid-June.
- 10 June 1949, Ellen Ridley for McCulloch: forwards a paper on the visual cortex for Shannon's comments, to be passed on to John Stroud, Hans-Lukas Teuber and Walter Pitts.
- 23 August 1949, Shannon to McCulloch: asks him to meet a friend, the science-fiction writer L. Ron Hubbard, about a hypnotic technique used in therapy; mentions his forthcoming paper on cryptography; has heard McCulloch was in England.
- 4 October 1950, McCulloch to Shannon: asks who at Bell Laboratories works on equations for the formants of phonemes, hoping to build “at least one variety of computing machine which can take dictation in at least one language.” Shannon's reply of 30 November, above, passed the letter to J. C. Steinberg.
Source
Warren S. McCulloch Papers (Mss.B.M139), American Philosophical Society, Philadelphia: Shannon correspondence. Quotations are transcribed from the page images in the APS Digital Library, where the letters can be read in full. They are quoted here, not reproduced.